The Inclusive Forum on Carbon Mitigation Approaches (IFCMA) an initiative by the OECD released a report February 09, 2024 regarding the fight against climate change, focusing on the carbon footprint measurement and decarbonization of industry sectors, called ‘Towards More Accurate, Timely, and Granular Product-Level Carbon Intensity Metrics.‘ While the report is rather reinforcing the known, whether through omission or commission by entities and individuals in the transitioning journey, it is an important read for corporate sustainability officers, private consulting firms, and etc.

The report argues the following and more:

1. There needs to be improvements made in the measurement of product-level carbon intensity metrics by comparing existing standards (i.e., IEA, IPCC, WSA, etc.), identifying complementarities and duplications, and proposing ways forward to improve the reliability and comparability of product-level carbon intensity metrics.

2. There should be ways and opportunities to scrutinize ongoing public initiatives to harmonize and enhance sustainability disclosure.

3. Various mitigation policies rely on carbon intensity metrics, including emissions trading schemes (ETS), and through these mitigation policies, open room to support efforts to make the calculation and use of carbon intensity more widespread.

4. International dialogue is key to identifying and implementing “common approaches” to support widespread emission calculation.

Upon reviewing the report, I’ve come away with some reflections, possibly known by many organizations and individuals tasked in transitioning. Below are my thoughts.

Here’s the thing: I am sure, be it whether you sit as part of an advisory group or governance board in an environmental initiative such as the Carbon Markets or Sustainability Disclosure, you may agree that there is some consolidation that can be made alongside other transition or reporting frameworks or compliance in an effort to bring these diverse climate and transition efforts together under a unified umbrella.

By centralizing compliance and framework reporting processes, a unified approach can potentially simplify management and resource allocation for entities involved in their transitioning efforts. This approach could enhance efficiency and redirect organizational resources effectively towards the crucial task of reducing emissions.

Understanding the importance of consolidation in transition reporting and disclosures is paramount. Recent exits from climate-focused initiatives, such as JPMorgan Chase and State Street’s investment subsidiary withdraw from Climate Action 100+ and Standard Chartered Plc and HSBC Plc leaving the Science Based Targets Initiative (SBTi), highlight the growing challenges of duplicated reporting frameworks and reporting costs for entities.

In July 2023, the Church of England Pensions Board exited the Net-Zero Asset Owner Alliance (NZAOA), citing the need for a clear focus on one net-zero initiative. Adam Matthew, Chief Responsible Investment Officer (CRIO) of the Church of England Pensions, emphasized the challenge organizations face in maintaining two reporting frameworks. He stated that despite their support for both the Net-Zero Asset Owner Alliance (NZAOA) and Net Zero Investment Framework (NZIF) initiatives, the size of the organization made it impractical to sustain two reporting frameworks. A clear focus on one net-zero initiative (NZIF) was deemed essential.

While criticisms may arise, accusing banks, pension funds, and others of backsliding on climate change commitments, the root cause lies in the myriad reporting and disclosure standards that need consolidation. Without a concerted effort to streamline and unify these standards, the trend of organizations departing from multiple initiatives may escalate.

Corporate sustainability officers will increasingly recognize the need for consolidation as a strategic move to efficiently manage and allocate capital and resources in the quest for decarbonization.

In a world facing pressing climate challenges and or natural catastrophes, the call to come together becomes more urgent than ever. Consolidation will offer a pathway to navigate the intricate landscape of climate initiatives, fostering efficient resource allocation and reinforcing the collective commitment to combating climate change and transitioning.

Hence, rather than waiting for further exits, there may be a compelling argument to build stronger collaborative efforts.

By: Kleber Ofume

 

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top
Scroll to Top